Extremism, Michael Moore and Education
OK here is my observation of the day. I saw that Michael Moore's new "documentary" film received a standing ovation at its premiere in the US. OK admittedly, I have not seen the movie, BUT.. I do know that M.&M.'s movie is saying there are ties between the Bushes and the Saudis. The implication is somehow they are all colluding for some monetary end or maybe to rule the world (which is a bad thing). Here is a simple observation. "W" is a fundamentalist, evangelical Christian. Fundamentalist, evangelical Christians in the 21st century do not tend to trust Muslims. To imply that there is a covenant between the two parties is simply grassy-knoll, conspiracy-wacko logic. OK, so the moon could be made of cheese "under the surface", but it makes no logical sense that it is. So M&M's theory is just a few minutes beyond of the twilight zone - it isn't the brightest. The point is, "why do Americans in the 21st century applaud this stuff like a bunch of raving Nazi's"? I say it is a sign of the failure of our educational system. We think conspiracy and lack of trust in what we see is critical thinking. To be critical is somehow to make speculations about what lies hidden under the surface. No!!! That is superstition. To be a critical thinker is the exact opposite of superstition. Hitler had superstitious theories and so does Osama. To be a critical thinker, you doubt speculation and superstition. Newton said the heart of science is humility. We do not in our ignorance pretend to know things that are actually just superstition. It is conspiracy and ignorance that is the hotbed of extremism. Such intellectual darkness leads to these "beyond the twilight zone" conspiracy theories. The root of our current political hatred is our failure to teach our children to think. As long as M&M keeps demonizing the opposition, can fascist intolerance be far behind?? Extremism is the superstition that demonizes our enemies. We must open our eyes and teach ourselves to "observe and learn".
2 Comments:
At June 15, 2004 at 11:05 PM, Mojoey said…
It always starts with “I have not seen the movie but….” and then a quick jump to a conclusion based on a preconceived position. I think this qualifies as a fallacy of non-support. I’m not sure through, I’ll have to check.
Michael Moore’s movies make you think, and they make you laugh. Anyone with a Brian knows that Moore is heavily biased against the right and will go to any length to make a point. Prejudging his movies based on long held beliefs flies in the face of the stated purpose of your Blog. Watch it, I mean really watch it. See it for what it is, then make your judgment. As for your conclusion – or should I say worldview. Wow.
Is it reasonable to question why Bush and Saudis play golf together? Yes, it is. Is it reasonable to suggest that because the Bush family is in the oil business we should look closer at the time the family has with the Saudis? Yes, it is. Do we need to hold our leaders accountable by watching, by questioning, by poking our noses into their private lives? Well, yes we do. Even if Bush is a fundamentalist, evangelical Christian, when money is involved, motives are suspect.
We are at war in Iraq based on the decisions of our President. There are no WMDs. There are few terrorists. We are fighting the wrong war in the wrong place and Michael Moore is asking why. Is that reasonable? Well yes.
You should change the name of your Blog to Watch and Learn
At June 16, 2004 at 8:50 AM, brad said…
Your perspective is very good. I am in agreement. My point is simply to question speculative thinking and those who rant and rave (emotionally) about their vain speculations. But certainly I have my own ideas and speculations but it is important to not to actually put faith in our own propaganda.
Post a Comment
<< Home